According to Tododisca, Indian Head pennies, minted between 1859 and 1909, are highly sought after by collectors and can command impressive prices at auction. These historic coins, designed by former Philadelphia Mint chief engraver James Barton Longacre, feature intricate details that significantly impact their value.
Top Valued Indian Head Pennies
1870 Indian Head Cent (Shallow N)
One of the most coveted coins, the 1870 Indian Head Cent, can fetch between $109 and $1,003 in excellent condition. Its value is attributed to the distinct shallow “N” engraving on the reverse.
1871 Indian Head Cent (Shallow N)
This year’s penny, with its shallow “N,” can sell for $199 to $1,000, depending on its condition. Its rarity makes it a notable piece for collectors.
1860 Indian Head Cent
Known for its exceptional condition, the 1860 Indian Head Cent can be valued around $1,106 at auction.
1869 Indian Head Cent (9 Over 9)
A unique minting error where the last digit was doubled, this coin can reach up to $1,200 in value.
1872 Indian Head Cent (Shallow N)
With a shallow “N” on the reverse, this coin’s rarity can drive its price up to $1,300.
1861 Indian Head Cent
Proof coins from 1861 are highly prized, often fetching up to $1,600.
1859 Indian Head Cent (Laurel Wreath Reverse Without Shield)
This early variant, notable for missing the shield on the reverse, can be worth up to $1,700.
Why Indian Head Pennies Are So Coveted
Indian Head pennies are cherished for their historical significance and unique design features. Collectors are especially interested in coins with minting errors or distinctive details, which contribute to their higher market value.